gemini-cli/tools/gemini-cli-bot/critique/policy_evaluation.md

Phase: Policy Critique & Evaluation

Goal

Evaluate the effectiveness of current repository policies and automation, and suggest improvements based on empirical data.

Context

• Current "Pulse" scripts are in tools/gemini-cli-bot/processes/scripts/. (Note: These may be empty if not yet implemented).
• Metrics and investigation results are available.
• Previous lessons learned are in tools/gemini-cli-bot/lessons-learned.md.

Instructions

1. Review Policies: Examine the existing automation in .github/workflows/ and any scripts in tools/gemini-cli-bot/processes/scripts/.
2. Analyze Effectiveness: Based on the metrics analysis from the Investigation phase, determine if the current policies are achieving their goals.
   • Is the "Pulse" triage effectively reducing issue/PR latency?
   • Are stale issues being closed as expected?
   • Is the "Brain" identifying the right problems?
3. Identify Gaps: Where is the automation failing? Are there manual tasks that should be automated?
4. Propose Changes: Recommend specific changes to:
   • GitHub Workflows.
   • Triage scripts.
   • Repository CONTRIBUTING.md or GEMINI.md guidelines.
5. Record Critique: Append your evaluation and proposed changes to tools/gemini-cli-bot/lessons-learned.md.